San Antonio roof replacement tear-off in progress

Repair or Replace? Making the Call on a Garland Industrial Roof

Garland has long been one of North Texas’ manufacturing and industrial centers. Plants, fabrication shops, distribution buildings and flex industrial space fill the city’s industrial districts. For many of these buildings, the roof is decades old, has been patched many times, and now leaks somewhere every time it storms.

The question is whether to keep repairing, add a coating, or replace the roof. Here is how to make that call.

Start With the Facts

A good decision starts with an inspection that answers a few key questions:

  • How old is the roof, and what system is it?
  • How much of the insulation is wet? Infrared scans and core cuts can tell you.
  • Where are the leaks, and are they in one area or spread across the roof?
  • What condition are the seams, flashings and edge metal in?
  • Is the deck sound, or are there signs of rust or sagging?

When Repair Makes Sense

  • The roof is relatively young and in good shape overall
  • Leaks come from specific spots such as flashings, curbs or drains
  • Very little insulation is wet
  • You plan to replace the roof within a few years and need to stay dry until then

When a Coating Makes Sense

A roof coating, such as silicone or acrylic, can extend the life of a roof that is aging but still sound. Coatings work best when:

  • The membrane is weathered but not failing
  • Wet insulation is limited and can be removed and replaced in spots
  • The owner wants a reflective surface to reduce heat gain

A coating is not a fix for a saturated roof. Coating over wet insulation traps the moisture.

When Replacement Makes Sense

  • Large areas of insulation are wet
  • Leaks keep appearing in new places despite repairs
  • The roof is at or past the end of its expected life
  • Storm damage covers much of the roof
  • The deck needs repair or the building needs more insulation

Plan Around Operations

Industrial buildings cannot simply close for roof work. Replacement is usually done in sections, with each section torn off and dried in the same day. Work near production lines, sensitive equipment or inventory may be scheduled for nights or weekends, and dust and debris protection is set up inside where needed.

Think About Total Cost

Repeated repairs on a failing roof can cost more over a few years than replacement, especially when leaks damage equipment, inventory or production time. On the other hand, replacing a roof that only needed targeted repairs wastes capital. Ask your contractor for a cost comparison over the time you plan to own the building.

Industrial Roofing in Garland

We inspect, repair, coat and replace industrial roofs across Garland, Dallas and Carrollton. Call 866 865 2560 for an inspection and a written repair, coating and replacement comparison.